Crime,Trauma and ‘The Prison Within’

Prison Within FI
The Prison Within film is blunt and insightful. It leaves little doubt it's past time to do more than punish the criminal act.

“I think there’s a lot of misconceptions about who people are in prison and who those people are that are coming home from prison…”

Narrated by Hill Harper, actor, activist and author of Letters to An Incarcerated Brother, The Prison Within shifts the focus from the criminal offense to what it takes to break criminal cycles.

This documentary tackles the US's mass incarceration problem with a humanizing examination of a restorative justice initiative inside San Quentin. This program considers acknowledgement, ownership, and trauma confrontation the core components of rehabilitation. It’s a mindful investigation of efforts to shift the “us and them” mindset in both prisoners and the non-incarcerated. 

Director  Kanterin Hervey chronicles survivors and prisoners sharing their experiences blended with facts and data in order to dig into the connections between trauma, poor choices, and criminality to shape this narrative.

Notably featured are: formerly incarcerated Soros Justice Fellow Troy Williams, Sam Johnson (Released), recently released after 23 years inside San Quentin, restorative justice expert - and MacArthur Genius Fellow - sujatha baliga, and Dionne Wilson, the wife of a police officer killed by a man sitting on San Quentin's Death Row. Each provides a different path into processing the hard concepts surrounding crime and punishment in the prison system. 

“The walls of prison aren’t just to keep people in, there to keep people out.”

Confronting the Trauma

Every participant advocates dealing honestly with the trauma histories that create perpetrators and victims in the first place. By the film's mid-way point, it's harrowingly clear how thin the line between criminal and citizen truly is as Baliga offers perspective-shifting personal examples of how much environment factors play into ending up in prison.

Both victims of crime and perpetrators speak on the impact of Victim Offender Education Group (VOEG), the one-of-a-kind program at San Quentin, has had on their lives. Hervey's unprecedented access allows these intimate confessions and emotional epiphanies to be witnessed by outsiders for the first time. 

The Prison WIthin

Sam and Eddie in The Prison Within

This documentary asks: why doesn’t society make the same efforts to confront formative trauma with prisoners if it can aid in recovery for both the prisoners and victims? It confronts the lack of interest in actually rehabilitating prisoners.

It's hard to deny that prison walls make it easier to reject the humanity of prisoners despite the fact that study after study, shows merely “warehousing” offenders has the exact opposite effect of crime prevention. This documentary is ultimately a measured, but tough, declaration that the time to repudiate society’s throw-away mentality has come. 

Reasons for Reformation

It’s a radical concept to consider confronting and exploring a prisoner’s trauma history as something more than giving criminals a chance to make excuses. Restorative justice expert Sujantha Baliga explains the importance of recognizing and treating trauma saying, “These aren’t excuses. These are explanations. And, if we don’t have explanations...we can’t possibly figure out how to make sure that this [crime] doesn’t happen again. 

“It hurt that it took coming to prison for something to click.”

This film is blunt and insightful. It leaves little doubt it's past time to do more than punish the criminal act. Nothing changes if shutting prisoner’s away without intensive rehabilitation programs continues. So, watch The Prison Within; then ask yourself the deceptively simple question Troy Williams poses near the end: “Which one [The criminal or the person interested in contributing to society] do you want coming home?” Because eventually, one is

The Prison Within Trailer

Prisoners incarcerated for murder inside San Quentin Prison transcend the barriers of the punitive prison system by working with victims of violent crime to unearth the root cause of their violence - untreated trauma. Each character undergoes a radical transformation, revealing how every human being, on both sides of the wall, can break free from their own personal prison.

Directed by Katherin Hervey
Runtime: 86 minutes
Produced by Katherin Hervey & Erin Kenway
Cinematography by Massimo Bardetti, Mario Furloni & Troy Williams
Editor Eric Frith Casting Director Nancy McBride
Original Music by Ruth Mendelson
Executive Producer Erin Kenway Co-Producers Eric Frith & Massimo Bardetti
Release: Beginning August 25, 2020, on Video-On-Demand/Digital platforms and available on Blu-Ray/DVD from Gravitas Ventures, a Red Arrow Studios company 

Follow more of our Film Festival Reviews and Coverage on our Press Page Page:

Follow us on Social Media:




Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.