Civil War Review

Share:
Final Score:4.3
4.3

This one Is going to be easy because I don’t think I’ve ever been entertained by a film and felt absolutely nothing for it at the same time.  Civil War, directed by Alex Garland, has been described as a “dystopian action thriller” and follows a group of journalists traveling from New York City to Washington DC to capture the capture of the POTUS by liberation rebel secessionist groups.  It’s a dystopian road movie that through a stream of random encounters along the trip shows how the breakdown of the country has affected large cities, rural areas, small towns, etc… with many of the events being horrifically graphic small warzones pitting the military verse civilians.  As an action thriller from the mind and eyes of Garland, the film gets the job done, which should be expected but the themes and the actual story or even point of the story don’t land and at many times can be frustrating.

The cast for this film is pretty stacked with their performances matching the intensity.  A gritty Kirsten Dunst playing established war photojournalist Lee Smith was not something I had in my bingo cards for 2024 films.  She’s played varying roles throughout her career but this one showed her age, as a career long actress.  Cailee Spaeny plays Jessie Collins, a reckless novice photojournalist who aspires to be like Lee.  We’re also blessed to be in the presence of Stephen McKinley Henderson as a respected veteran Journalist and mentor.  We also have Wagner Moura as Joel, a Reuters journalist.  There are a few surprise cameos sprinkled throughout the film with some of the more notable appearances being Nick Offerman and Jesse Plemons.  The chemistry between the group of traveling journalists is very palpable, and even their conversations and opinions about the current state of the warring country, and feelings towards their careers provide well written dialogue and a few funny moments.  The cast is well-rounded and through their conversations help the pacing of the film.

The issues start to arise when certain understandings of this country operates for certain groups go ignored by the writers and directors because in my opinion I just don’t think they had the experience or appreciation for them.  What stood out immediately was the elder veteran and mentor being an old Black man who’s still got on more war report left in him, so he goes on this trip with 2 white women photographers and one white passing photographer, him being the only visible person of color initially.  The group later joint by some other people of color and of course that doesn’t end well.  The film just glosses over what should be the loudly expressed apprehensions of a Black man traveling from NYC to DC, with his destination being  Charlottesville, VA, of all places.  We’re talking about a white civil war in the USA.  Charlottesville is at the very top of the east coast list for places your Black ass should not be going any where near.  There’s also scenes of other minorities having way too much fun during this war, which may actually speak more to how those monitories maybe don’t always feel as othered or as minor as Black people in this country.  But again, that doesn’t end well for them.  I don’t know who decided a press pass was Switzerland but no way that’s going to fly for people of color during a national insurrection.

Then there’s the aspirations and reckless actions of Jessie, and her mentor becoming Lee and Joel, two photographers with two vastly different approaches to war journalism.  The photos taken during the trip are supposed to capture the events but seems more the point of humanizing the people in this war in life and sadly death.  That part is fine.  It’s the final act of the film that made my eyes roll out of my head.  Is the message supposed to be we’re so desensitized from all the images we see on the media that even being there in the moment won’t prevent us from getting the perfect shot of a tragic even that arguably we caused?  So now we’re capitalizing off our own ignorance, mistakes, and atrocities.  And who is even going to see these photos or publish them at home when the damn war is at home, and it’s literally against our own government.  One thing for sure, the politics of the film are just as dumb in their alignment to where current events could put us in the very near future.

As pure war film, Jesse Plemons and a terrible person on screen entertainment goes, the film satisfies.  But I don’t know why this movie was made.  I don’t know who this movie is for.  I’m not sure what message this film hopes it’s audience can walk away with.  What does any of this add to the conversation being that conversation feeling so close to home?

 

Streaming now on Youtube, Apple TV, FandangoAtHome, Amazon Video, etc

♦♦

 

Director: Alex Garland
Writers:  Alex Garland

Starring:

Runtime:  109 Minutes

Synopsis:  A group of war photojournalists travel from NY to DC to interview the President as a nationwide civil war comes to an end. 

 


Like what you hear? Subscribe so you don’t miss an episode!

Follow us on Twitter:

Want more podcast greatness? Sign up for a MTR Premium Account!

 

Comments

comments

Share:

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.