Arizona: The Battleground State That Shouldn’t Be

Battleground states are states that, due to changing demographics, fluctuations in party affiliation, and a large number of undecided voters, have become incredibly important “toss ups” in a presidential election. This usually happens over a long period of time. As political parties change their policies and platforms and social issues become more prevalent and divisive, people find themselves siding with parties that they historically have not. None of this, however, is the case in the newest battleground state: Arizona.
Arizona is not a traditional battleground state by any stretch of the imagination. The state has not been won by a Democrat in a presidential election since 1996, and that year was the first time a Democrat carried the state since 1948. In 2008 and 2012 John McCain and Mitt Romney won Arizona by 8.5% and 9% of the popular vote respectively. The most fascinating thing about those wins is that they both won all but the exact same 4 counties (Apache, Santa Cruz, Pima and Coconino) in their elections. Arizona doesn’t have a long history of flipping back and forth between Democrats and Republicans. In fact, all of the state government of Arizona are Republicans. As you can see, this is a state that is usually pretty solidly red. A state whose 11 electoral college votes should be guaranteed to the Republican nominee for President. However, none of that is the case this year.
According to the poll average available on Real Clear Politics, Trump currently leads Clinton in Arizona by 0.7%. The poll average is based on the aggregate of polls conducted in the state by Gravis, NBC/WSJ/Marist, OH Predictive Insights and Emerson between August 27th and October 4th. Fivethirtyeight currently gives Hillary Clinton a 56% chance of winning Arizona in the current Election Forecast. Clinton is even leading Trump in Maricopa county, a solidly red county, 41.2% to 32.4%, according to Arizona Republic/Morrison/Cronkite News poll. These numbers become even more fascinating when we break down the history and current party affiliation as it exists in Arizona.
We haven’t seen massive demographic shifts or change in party affiliation. In fact, we’ve seen party affiliation stay relatively uniform. In 2008, the total number of those registered as Democrats in Arizona was 935,638 (or 35% of the total voting population in Arizona), in 2012, that number was 946,974 (30%) and in 2016, that number is 990,417 (30%). Conversely, Republicans in 2008 totaled 1,045,365 (38%), in 1,130,164 (36%) in 2012, and 1,161,816 (35%) in 2016.
There are a total of 15 counties in Arizona. In 2008, 10 were majority Democrat and 5 were majority Republican. In 2012, 7 were majority Democrat and 8 were majority Republican. In 2016, 7 are majority Democrat and 8 are majority Republican. These numbers show that Democrats have not made major inroads into Arizona while Republicans have mostly been sitting firmly in control. The only counties to switch their majority in terms of party preference (Gilda, Graham and Pinal) all did so during the 2012 Presidential cycle and all switched from Democrat to Republican. Frankly, nothing has changed that would warrant Arizona being the battleground state that it has become. Republicans were in the majority in 2008, 2012 and are still the majority in terms of party affiliation in 2016. The reason behind these extraordinary numbers and the position that Democrats find themselves in is Donald J. Trump, the Republican nominee himself.
Donald Trump himself has been extremely untenable. Trump’s comments and actions have put him beyond the pale to many Republican voters and leaders in the party. This has caused many Republicans to turn away from Trump and has created situations like the one we see in Arizona, where what should be an easy win for Republicans is slowly slipping from their grasp and they are powerless to stop it.
Much has been made of a so-called “Trump effect”. The idea that Donald Trump, as a Presidential nominee, is normalizing bigotry and heinous comments that are being repeated by children all across this country. While that is cause for concern, the real Trump effect is what were are seeing in places like Arizona and Georgia. States that have been reliable wins for Republicans that now are battleground states due simply to the inclusion of Donald J. Trump on their General Election ballots.







